To Slap Or Not To Slap

What would you do if another parent slapped your child?This is the theme of a new series called The Slap. I was instantly curious after seeing the commercials for it because not only does it have a top notch cast but it explores a topic that usually leads to very heated discussions. There have been many times, in my own life, where I have witnessed other children acting out, horrendously acting out and wondered where in the world their adult is. This show explores that and many other issues besides the obvious one.

Here’s a quick rundown of what happens in the first episode (spoiler alert).

At a family BBQ there is an altercation between one family’s 4 year old child, Hugo and another child, Rocco who looks about 8 to 10 years old. Hugo has been an absolute bear all day long. He’s broken things, torn up a flower bed, tried to break an iPad, all the while Hugo’s parents are both too busy socializing to keep an eye on their child. Except of course when the mother is breast feeding him, but that’s an entirely different rant. Really lady, he’s four and we know he’s four because they are talking about putting him in Preschool/Kindergarten because he needs socialization and the parents are against it saying they would rather home school.

At this point, it seems to me that Hugo’s parents are just different from the other parents that are there at the BBQ. They are definitely portrayed as being poorer, anti-establishment and free rangers. They even dress the mother’s character in a “bohemian” way to drive that point home that they are “different”.

While the children are in the back yard and the adults are enjoying drinks on the deck, the kids begin playing baseball. Hugo doesn’t want to be out and begins to throw a fit when the kids say his turn is over. During the course of Hugo’s fit, he begins to wave a bat at Rocco’s head and that’s when Rocco’s father asks Hugo’s parents to do something. Hugo’s parents stay seated and “politely” tell their son to stop. When Hugo continues to attempt to hit Rocco with the baseball bat, Rocco’s father gets up and runs over to his son’s defense. He then takes the bat from Hugo, grabs him by the shoulders and yells at him that what he’s doing is wrong. In response, Hugo kicks him in the leg and that is the moment when Rocco’s father slaps Hugo across the face. It is only then that Hugo’s parents decide to leave the table and do something about the situation.

After watching this episode, I wondered what I would do. I was raised in a spare the rod and spoil the child household. I rear my children the same way. Do I think that mode of discipline is right for every family or every child? Absolutely not. There’s more than one way to skin a cat. I do not under any circumstances think that the correct response to this situation was to hit another parent’s child. That’s their kid, they need to handle it, case closed. That said, if your child is waving a bat at my kid’s head and you decide not to get up and intervene, we’re going to have words. The issue is with the parent, not the child. Am I going to get up and take the bat out of your child’s hand? Yes. Am I probably going to come after you with said bat? Quite possibly, but it depends on whether or not I’ve had my Wheaties that morning. Either way, I’m stopping the situation if you don’t.

What is absolutely ridiculous about the entire scene is that Hugo’s parents sat there and did not respond until after the slap occurred. What parent in their right mind is going to let their child wave a bat at another kid’s head? If the roles were reversed and say for instance, I was not aware of what my child was doing at the time and another parent said, “Hey, your kid is waving a bat around”. I’m jumping out of my chair and handling that situation because it’s not okay at all for my child to do that. Sitting in my seat and asking him politely to stop, is not an option. That’s an option when he’s throwing sandbox sand but not waving around a blunt object that has the potential to do serious harm.

If it were me, I would have grabbed the bat, made my apologies to the parent and made my kid apologize to the other kid. I think Rocco’s father was well within his rights to intervene; his child could have been in serious danger. I don’t care if the kid is four and speaking from my forensic background, it doesn’t take much force if you accidentally hit someone in the right place.

The question is, where do you draw the line at protecting your child, especially when the people who should get involved, opt out?

What would you do?


16 thoughts on “To Slap Or Not To Slap

  1. I watch very little TV, but I had heard of the show, and it had intrigued me. (I didn’t read the full description of the episode for that reason, because I want to catch up with the series one day.) Behavior endangering others must never be tolerated, but touching or hitting a child not yours crosses a boundary.


    1. I don’t watch a lot myself mostly for lack of time. The show has a great cast so I would definitely say watch the first episode and see if you like it. At this point, it seems like the show could go either way, be really great or horrible.


  2. I have also seen previews of the show and wondered how they could create an entire show around one incident. In real life, I would probably do just as you suggested; grabbed the bat from the kid before he did any harm to my child or any other child – but not touch that child unless restraining him from harming someone else was absolutely necessary. And then, in the case of him being that small, I might just carry him AND the bat to his parents, and firmly tell them his behavior is NOT acceptable!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Oh I haven’t ever heard of this. But, to answer your question no one touches my children. No. One. I wouldn’t grab the Bat, I’d remove my child. If he was the one about to be hit or the one having the fit. My child would be removed from the situation. If he were the one who was about to be hit and the parents did nothing I would leave. Yep, I don’t have time for people who don’t deal with issues like that. If he were to be the one about to hit he would be removed and left sitting with me or doing something else LESS fun.
    I wouldn’t ever touch anyone elses child, nor would I allow anyone to touch mine. If anyone were to touch mine, Oh boy!

    Liked by 1 person

  4. I haven’t seen the show as I wasn’t sure if it would really be any good. I don’t have kids yet, but I’d like to think that when I do – I’ll be responsible enough to watch them. I’m sure I won’t be perfect and I won’t catch everything, but if someone brought a negative situation to my attention, I’d most definitely take action instead of passively saying stop. I don’t think I’d handle it well if someone were to slap them!

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Unfortunately, I don’t watch a lot of TV. Mostly because it’s made up of reality TV that’s not so reality. However, I must say it’s never okay to slap another person’s child. It’s never okay to put your hands on another’s child for any reason for that matter. In this case, if he felt his child was in danger or being bullied it was best he left or confront the parents. No you shouldn’t have to leave, but as an adult you have to be able to make decisions that is best although may not always seem fair. Not only could hitting a child cause legal repercussions such as being charged with child abuse. It’s not your child to discipline.


  6. I saw the preview for this show and laughed. My initial thought was how could they possibly create a whole series around a slap?? I still haven’t seen the show, but it intrigued me enough to think about it. I don’t think that I would ever hit someone else’s child, especially in a situation where I’m able to remove my child from the threat. That being said, I would have definitely had some choice words for Hugo’s parents because it’s apparent that he’s not being taught appropriate behavior and in essence, their lack of parenting is putting other people (including my child) at risk.

    Liked by 1 person

  7. Never heard of this tv show before. I will have to go check it out. 🙂
    I don’t have a child, but if someone touched him/her, it would be the end of them(not literally).
    Thanks for sharing!


  8. This show totally intrigued me when I heard about it. I couldn’t agree more with your take on it. I think the father went a little further than he should have but I get where he was coming from. It’s a situation I hope I never find myself in.

    Liked by 1 person

  9. I don’t watch much TV myself because of lack of time and if I do I only watch reality TV. I certainly won’t be watching the show but if someone laid a hard on my child they would literally regret it. It is a really interesting thought thought. I just think I would personally flip out.


  10. I didn’t read your entire post because I am still behind on this show. I have not yet seen the first episode, so I don’t want to ruin it for myself. I do agree. This is a very touchy subject. Like you, there have been times when a child is acting out and their adult is either nowhere to be seen OR (even worse) just ignoring the bad behavior. What do you do? I don’t believe in hitting children. It’s the way I was raised. I WILL in a heartbeat get onto any child that is acting out. I don’t care if the adult is not okay with it. The way I feel is if I don’t say something then nobody else will.


Comments are appreciated!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s